By Jen Saarbach & Kristen Kelly, Co-Founders of The Wall Street Skinny
![]()
Our HOT TAKE on grifters’ attempts to change your mind, something Wall Street knows all too well…
CAUTION: SPOILERS AHEAD
I hate to break it to you, but the subject of Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim’s documentary “You Can See Everything” isn’t Elizabeth Holmes.
It’s you. And if you’re anything like us, you probably got played.
Let me explain.

First of all, it’s worth mentioning the genesis of the movie itself. Elizabeth Holmes is best known as the founder of Theranos, a company that claimed its device could run hundreds of medical tests from a single drop of blood. Spoiler alert: it couldn’t. In 2022, Holmes was convicted on four counts of wire fraud and conspiracy for deceiving her investors, and was sentenced to 11 years in prison.
After her conviction, the story goes, Holmes and her fiancé Billy Evans approached A24, the independent film studio known for taking on risky, unconventional material (like one of my favorites, “Everything Everywhere All at Once”). Months later, rumor got around that they were looking for someone to run the project. The rumor reached Lance Oppenheim, the documentarian behind “Some Kind of Heaven”, “Ren Faire”, and “Spermworld”. He asked Nathan Fielder to join him on the project. Fielder, for those of you unfamiliar with his body of work, is a Canadian comedian whose projects (like “Nathan for You”, “The Rehearsal”, and “the Curse”) reveal a special interest in both magic and social experiments.
So the documentary didn’t start with Nathan Fielder reaching out to Holmes and Evans. Instead, it started with Holmes and Evans angling to get their faces on camera.
While I can’t presume to have full knowledge of their intentions, it seems logical that Holmes and Evans wanted to rehabilitate her negative image. How many times have we seen convicted criminals and grifters subsequently embraced by society following their fall from grace, especially on Wall Street? Look no farther than Jordan Belfort (whom Leonardo DiCaprio depicted in “The Wolf of Wall Street”), Michael Milken, Martha Stewart…I could go on.
Media cycles have never been shorter, and everybody loves a comeback story.
It logically follows that one would assume the goal of this movie from Holmes and Evans’ standpoint was to offer fresh insight into Elizabeth Holmes’ character that might sway public sentiment in her favor.
While I imagine the resulting product bore little resemblance to what they originally envisioned, it might not seem that far off at first.
At face value, “You Can See Everything” appears to be asking how you feel about Holmes’ character based on what you see in the film alone.
And the central question seems to be: which of the following is she?
- A liar who knows the truth, yet deliberately deceives you in order to achieve a self-serving outcome,
- Someone who has lied to themselves so thoroughly that they have created a delusion that they believe to be the truth, and when they tell you “their truth”, they do not realize they are lying, or
- A woman looking for love in all the wrong places who has been repeatedly manipulated by men as a useful idiot.
Why these three options? Well, because each of these possibilities was argued at her trial — the former by the prosecution and the latter two by the defense.
By asking us to consider all three, first through a direct (but highly curated) observation of the subject, then through a reenactment of select scenes we could not directly observe, the movie invites us to render a verdict on the question of Elizabeth’s character and culpability.
Except: it’s impossible for us to do so.
Instead, I believe the film is inviting us to be part of a social experiment where we are explicitly TOLD we are being deceived…then asking us if we buy it anyway. The entire premise gets flipped on its head.
In this article, we’ll recap the basic facts of the Theranos case, walk through how the film orchestrates the emotional stakes, and reveal our final verdict on the documentary everybody can’t stop thinking about.
Elizabeth Holmes is the daughter of a former foreign policy aide and a former Enron executive (and no, the irony of this is neither lost on Fielder nor the audience). Her father worked on one of Enron’s clean energy projects before transitioning to USAID and other political initiatives, so to be clear: it’s not like he was camped out in Andy Fastow’s office finding the next creative SPV to hide an underwater asset in.
Holmes matriculated at Stanford in 2002 (the same year we started at Princeton and Brown), intending to major in Chemical Engineering. After researching microfluidic systems, microarrays, and the SARS virus, she reportedly became frustrated with the relatively low speed and cumbersome size of conventional testing equipment.
She wanted to make things smaller and faster. Holmes initially filed a patent to develop a “micropatch” to diagnose and deliver treatment for infections. When that idea was shot down by the Dean of Stanford’s School of Medicine for being wholly unrealistic, she pivoted. Her next concept was a small, portable device capable of running hundreds of diagnostic tests from a single finger-prick of blood. The company name, “Theranos”, was a portmanteau of the device’s two-fold aims: therapy and diagnosis.
Holmes dropped out, and needed to raise money. Her parents agreed to let her use her college tuition fund to start the business, and a family friend Tim Draper was her first outside investor. But soon she had names like Don Lucas (who originally backed Oracle and Larry Ellison), Larry Ellison himself, and ATA Ventures backing her.
By 2010, she’d raised some 90mmatavaluationof~1bn. Later fundraising rounds brought in Rupert Murdoch (who eventually became the largest single investor with some $125mm at stake), the Walton family, the Cox family, the DeVos family, Carlos Slim, Robert Kraft, and others. Her board featured former Secretaries of State George Shultz and Henry Kissinger and former Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis.
By 2014 when the Series C closed, the company’s valuation stood around $9bn. Holmes’ economic stake was reportedly half the company (not to mention her 99% voting control), leading press outlets like Forbes to label her the youngest female self-made billionaire at the time.
Yet, despite all of the cumulative investing prowess of that prestigious donor list, not a single one of these investors had actually SEEN the device they were paying for.
Theranos was conducting what turned out to be, in hindsight, a nearly perfect inversion of the due diligence process. They claimed their device contained trade secrets that were *SO VALUABLE* that they couldn’t possibly be inspected, lest those precious secrets be compromised.
There were no open product demonstrations, and definitely no audited financials. Instead, what investors were handed were “validation reports” bearing the logos of companies like Pfizer and Schering-Plough. Investors took those to mean that the device had been independently tested and verified by those reputable third parties.
The reality? Holmes admitted in her trial that she personally copied and pasted those logos on the reports herself. The device was never validated because it was never actually able to live up to its promises.
But Holmes was undeterred by that pesky fact. The device was sold into Walgreens, and thousands of patients submitted samples via the Theranos device. Those samples were then diluted to achieve the minimum sample size needed by conventional testing facilities and run through Siemens analyzers in concealed operation within Theranos’ offices. Between the failures of the Theranos device and the dilution required for conventional testing, Theranos’ customers received erroneous results ranging from “your potassium levels are so low, you should be dead” to “you’ve suffered a miscarriage”, when neither turned out to be true.
There was more going on behind the scenes than fraud in the lab. Enter Sunny Balwani. When Holmes was 18, he was a 37-year old newly minted decamillionaire who had just sold a dot-com called CommerceBid at the top of that bubble. Holmes met him while studying abroad in Beijing the summer before matriculating at Stanford. He joined Theranos in 2009 as its President and COO, as well as ultimately being Vice Chairman of the Board, after personally guaranteeing a $10mm loan to keep the company alive in the wake of the GFC.
Unbeknownst to the rest of the board and investors, Balwani and Holmes were also secretly dating and living together the whole time. And the entire sham was held up by a series of threats and intimidation handed down from Balwani himself. Balwani reportedly screamed at engineers in meetings and fired anyone who raised concerns.
How did it all fall apart?
In 2013, two young Theranos lab associates noticed that Theranos’ devices constantly failed quality control checks. Those failures were then deleted from the data set. And when it came to proficiency tests, all reported results came from tests run on conventional Siemens machines, not the Theranos devices.
One of those associates was Tyler Shultz, a new Stanford grad and grandson of George Shultz (former Secretary of State, economist, and one of the board’s most prominent names). When Shultz emailed Holmes to question these practices, Balwani responded with insults. Shultz quit, reported the company to the NY State Dept. of Health, and ultimately teamed up with John Carreyrou at The Wall Street Journal to blow the whistle on Theranos. Theranos responded with costly legal intimidation tactics — going so far as to ask Rupert Murdoch to personally kill the WSJ story, which he declined — and unfortunately even Tyler’s grandfather didn’t believe him.
The other associate, Erika Cheung, filed a complaint with the Federal lab regulator, triggering an inspection that eventually led to the lab being shut down.
Both associates were the victims of intimidation tactics and legal threats, ranging from being followed by private investigators to nearly half a million dollars in legal fees.
But even worse was the fate of Theranos’ Chief Scientist, Ian Gibbons.
Gibbons was a British biochemist with a PhD from Cambridge, hired in 2005 as one of the first experienced scientists at the company and listed as co-inventor on a large number of Theranos’ patents. When he concluded that the device didn’t work (something he reportedly confided in his wife), Holmes fired him, only to bring him back into the company with a lower title and no direct reports. He was subpoenaed in 2013 to give a testimony about Theranos’ patents, but committed suicide the night before he was due to be deposed.
Reportedly, when Gibbons’ widow called Holmes to notify her of Gibbons’ death, the only response she received from Holmes was a request that all confidential company materials and property be promptly returned.
Carreyrou’s story ran October 15th, 2015 (almost eleven years to the day before the movie premiered in theaters). Within a year, the lab was shut down and Theranos voided every test result from 2014 and 2015. Walgreens sued for $140mm — a case it settled for $30mm.
But that wasn’t the full extent of it. In March of 2018, Holmes settled with the SEC and was hit with both a $500k fine and a 10-year ban on serving as an officer or director of a public company. By June of 2018, a Federal grand jury indicted Holmes and Balwani on eleven counts of wire fraud and conspiracy.
This brings us to the trial. In order to prove my earlier point about the three alternative framings of Elizabeth, I’ll explain the trial briefly through these three original lenses.
Option 1: Holmes lied for personal benefit.
This was the assertion of the prosecution.
In quite literally their opening statement, prosecutors asserted that Holmes was “out of time and out of money, [so she] decided to lie”.
Prosecutors said “this scheme brought her fame, it brought her honor, and it brought her adoration.”
Amongst the evidence they cited against Holmes:
- Several different investors testified that Holmes told them her device was being used on medevac helicopters in Afghanistan and that it was contributing to higher survival rates. General Mattis himself took the stand and said it had never been deployed anywhere.
- A Pfizer scientist testified that he reviewed the technology in 2008 and declined to work with Theranos.
- Senior scientists and lab directors brought evidence to Holmes that the device wasn’t ready and she decided to push ahead with the Walgreens deal.
- Texts between Holmes and Balwani, in addition to being amorous in nature, coordinated the “need to get ahead of all of it” when it came to their efforts to suppress the WSJ story.
Option 2: Holmes sincerely believed her own story
This was the first positioning by the defense.
This was the thesis summed up in the defense’s opening arguments:
“Failure is not a crime. Trying your hardest and coming up short is not a crime…she was motivated by mission, not money…Holmes remains steadfast in her belief in this technology.”
- Their rebuttal to the Afghanistan medical helicopters lie? Well, she didn’t lie…that was a misunderstanding. They reduced it to an issue of semantics, claiming Holmes merely insinuated the device HAD THE POTENTIAL to improve outcomes for soldiers. And it had, after all, been flown on a helicopter, somewhere, at some point. Holmes did admit that she knew telling anyone that the device had been used in Afghanistan would have been false. But effectively defense argued she was guilty of no more than being a poor communicator.
- The Pfizer logo? Holmes said she truly believed the work had been done with Pfizer and didn’t think she’d be misleading anyone if she put their logo on those reports.
Option 3: Sunny was the real villain; Holmes was merely a lovelorn useful idiot
This was the secondary positioning of the defense.
- Holmes testified that Sunny was emotionally and sexually abusive, and that he controlled everything from her communications to her diet to her sleep and her schedule.
- Holmes testified that she had been raped at Stanford and then Sunny became her refuge as she recovered.
- And while she admitted that he never forced her into any specific action related to her charges, she testified that Sunny’s abuse and control “impacted everything about who [she] was”.
Ultimately, both Holmes and Sunny were both convicted of wire fraud and conspiracy. Holmes was only guilty of defrauding investors, while Sunny was additionally convicted of defrauding patients. Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in prison and ordered to pay ~$452mm in restitution.
The documentary begins 34 days prior to her reporting for prison.
In the first 90 minutes, we see comedian Nathan Fielder embedding himself with Holmes, her fiance Billy Evans, and their two young children.
In the second half, Fielder enlists the help of Amanda Seyfried, the actress who played Holmes in “The Dropout” (a Hulu series portraying Holmes’ story), to answer Fielder’s questions that remain after filming with the family. Together, they attempt to get to the bottom of what Fielder claims are inconsistencies he perceived in Holmes’ character. They do so by rehearsing, reenacting, and reacting to segments that happened off-camera based on Fielder’s retelling of them…in addition to filming new segments with Billy.
Now, as we said from the beginning: there’s a promise inherent in the title “You Can See Everything”. To many viewers, I think that implicit promise was the conveyance of some new or previously concealed insight into Holmes’ character to help us determine the nature of her culpability. Maybe a “why” when it comes to how she behaves? A convincing case for a clinical diagnosis? Or maybe even a persuasive argument as to why she thinks she was wrongfully convicted?
Instead what we got was effectively a new trial, taking place between the grainy close-ups and full-frontal surprises, with us as the jury. And it’s all based on evidence that sends us on a wild goose chase as far as possible in the opposite direction of the original question of her character.
If you trace the narrative arc of the documentary, you can see Fielder tackles the three potential assessments of Holmes’ character in a precise parallel to the way they were framed at trial.
Option 1: Holmes is a liar for personal benefit
This plays out through the question of “did Elizabeth know about the documentary money?”
To be clear, the financial stakes of Theranos never get litigated in this film. Instead, what comes up are the financial stakes of the documentary itself.
Fielder tells us that, off camera, Evans aggressively negotiated for an economic stake in the film. Despite allegedly insisting that this would compromise the objectivity of the film, A24 agreed.
The key question Nathan asks: did Elizabeth, conveniently out of the room at the time, know about it? She explicitly says on camera “why would I lie? I mean, it’s not like I have any economic benefit from this whatsoever.”
Fielder and Seyfried play detective to try and figure this out.
And Fielder uses this very plot point to call into question his own reliability as a narrator. In recounting his confrontation of Elizabeth, he changes his recollection from “she knew they were talking about ‘it’” to “she knew they were talking about ‘something‘”. One option seems to suggest a willing participation in a scheme, the other seems more exculpatory.
It is this precise change that leads Amanda Seyfried to accuse Fielder of being overly sympathetic to Holmes, a point many believe to be genuine from him. I’ll get to that later.
As Kristen so aptly pointed out on our podcast,
- If the money did go to Elizabeth, it would immediately go towards paying restitution towards her investors, so the idea that she’d benefit seems ludicrous.
- Billy and Elizabeth are not legally married. Given he negotiated the deal, the money could in fact have gone to him without her benefitting whatsoever.
Ultimately, just as we can never be sure what her involvement was without seeing the original interaction, an end title card tells us Billy decided to withdraw his economic claim before the documentary was published.
If you were hanging your hat on this one issue to determine your view on Elizabeth’s character, you’re SOL. Fielder and Oppenheim have constructed it in a way that ensures it can never be satisfactorily resolved from the evidence of the film alone.
Option 2: Holmes believes her own story
This plays out through the conversation about the device and the “Who’s on First” sequences, both mimicking the semantics argument at trial.
In one scene, Fielder and Holmes sit at the table looking at her device, which she says “could” do what she claimed. They proceed to play with the word “could” and its conceivable meanings. Did she mean “it could possibly one day in the future when pigs can fly be able to do what she hoped?” Or did she mean it was affirmatively capable of doing so already? Elizabeth never clarifies for the audience, and simply self-deprecatingly suggests perhaps she’s just a poor communicator.
Later, Nathan has her watch the classic comedy sketch “Who’s on First?” to illustrate what the experience of dialoguing with her felt like. She insists she doesn’t understand the sketch. Nathan is dumbfounded that anyone could fail to get the joke.
These sequences suggest that she is so literal-minded and so fundamentally clueless about how other people interpret her words that she can’t have been lying, because she doesn’t process language the way a liar would.
This is where Kristen was open to at least believing her in that scene. As someone who’d never seen the sketch and didn’t quite get it in theaters (mostly because she was texting Jen at the same time) she was willing to entertain the theory that Elizabeth might have been telling the truth at that moment. The question though was whether we can extrapolate Elizabeth’s misunderstanding this to the broader Theranos case itself.
The answer is likely not.
Well, knowing what we know OUTSIDE the film, Holmes has demonstrated herself perfectly capable of using figurative language throughout her entire body of communications on record. She called Theranos “her religion”. She said “next to every glass ceiling, there’s a woman with a hammer.” Even in the text exchanges with Sunny that were presented at trial, she said things like a compliment “coming from my tiger means the whole universe to me”.
If we stick to the facts of the movie alone, it’s still entirely possible that Holmes’ neurodivergence is a large part of the problem. That is, until you realize that Fielder himself is simultaneously putting his own brand of neurodivergence on display. Nathan and Elizabeth seem so similar in this regard, but while Elizabeth seems to think it’s a “get out of jail free” card, Nathan shows you that it in no way shape or form stands in the way of him being ready, willing, and able to manipulate others.
Case in point: the swimming scenes.
We see an interaction captured on film where Elizabeth asks Nathan to come swimming in the ocean with her, leaning towards him and saying “I like to go all the way in”. Whether she intends it or not, there’s obviously a dual meaning here in terms of the emotional boundary between documentarian and subject. Nathan awkwardly gives her the blunt reply: “I don’t like cold water.” This scene got a laugh in the theater, as it played like two awkward people trying to have a conversation while failing to uphold social norms, boundaries, and etiquette.
Yet in subsequent scenes, we get glimpses of a couple swimming together in the ocean, whose faces we can’t quite identify. Then, at the very end of the film, we get a closeup showing that it is, in fact, Nathan and Elizabeth swimming together.
Many took this as a sign that the boundary between documentarian and subject had been obliterated. Others went so far as to interpret this as evidence that he’d become enamored of Elizabeth (a take Kristen shared briefly, then reconsidered, and one I never shared whatsoever). This is where Kristen felt played. My take? Nathan uses this manipulation to warn you — to insist — that he cannot be trusted.
Instead of being exculpatory, these scenes deftly use comedy and misdirection to prove that word play works both ways. And, when combined with Option 3, only serve as additional red herrings to suggest Holmes has limited agency or capacity to manipulate.
Option 3: Billy is the real villain; Elizabeth is the lovesick useful idiot
This plays out through Seyfried’s confrontation with Billy and the question of whether Holmes consented to his use of her image and X account.
This is where I felt the most played.
Within the opening moments of the documentary, we see Elizabeth ineffectually stirring eggs instead of properly scrambling them. Billy grabs the bowl out of her hand in frustration. It’s a minor domestic scene that hints at the question of control.
That question soon becomes more overt. After Holmes’ imprisonment, Billy takes over her image (specifically the photo she said on camera she “hates”) and her Twitter account.
And soon Billy starts to seem almost dangerous. He expresses his rage at Amanda Seyfried and the creators of “The Dropout”. We see his paranoia about being followed, his attempts to control the narrative about his own company, his alarming need to carry a gun 24/7, and his assertion that he effectively has a dead man’s switch in play if anything happens to him. Evans even intervenes to control Fielder’s access to communicate with Holmes in prison.
But honestly I think his remarks on how “fit” Holmes looks in prison and his admiration for her newfound “abs” —